Asked by Akash Iqbal on Sep 24, 2024

Below is a source followed by passage(s) from student papers. If the student has summarized, directly quoted, or indirectly quoted the source correctly, select "Correct." If you believe the source is incorrectly summarized or plagiarized, select "Incorrect."
"In May, scientists in the Gulf of Mexico began tracking plumes of methane and oil droplets drifting up to 30 miles from the broken [BP oil] well, at depths of 3,000 to 4,000 feet. One of those scientists was University of Georgia biogeochemist Mandy Joye, who has spent years studying hydrocarbon vents and brine seeps in the deep Gulf. She found a plume the size of Manhattan, and its methane levels were highest she had ever measured in the Gulf. As bacteria feast on spilled oil and methane, they deplete the water of oxygen; at one point Joy found oxygen levels dangerously low for life a water layer 600 feet thick, at depths where fish usually live. Since waters in the deep Gulf mix very slowly, she said, such depleted zones could persist for decades."
⎯ Bourne, Joel. "The Gulf of Oil: The Deep Dilemma."
Green . Boston: Wadsworth, 2013. 100-112. Print.
Student version: The 2010 oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico from one of the BP Oil Company's wells was one of the most environmentally damaging spills in the history of oil drilling. Bourne says that, according to one University of Georgia scientist, huge columns of oil and methane in the Gulf have already led to depleted oxygen supplies in the water. As a result, vast areas once home to fish may be unable to support life for years to come. (110-111) .

A) Correct
B) Incorrect

Biogeochemist Mandy Joye

A scientist known for her research in marine biogeochemistry, focusing on microbial ecology and biogeochemical processes in oceanic environments.

Hydrocarbon Vents

Openings in the Earth's surface from which hydrocarbon-rich fluids, such as oil or natural gas, escape.

Methane Levels

The concentration or amount of methane gas in a particular environment, critical for tracking climate change and environmental health.

  • Appraise the precision of students' usage of sources with reference to the original texts.
  • Understand the environmental consequences of actions or incidents such as oil spills.