Asked by Mustafa Sufiyan on Apr 28, 2024
Verified
For which argument below are the premises independent?
A) Premises: The river's water level is falling.Fish require a high water level.Conclusion: The river's fish are endangered.
B) Premises: It is not safe to smoke around an oxygen tank.Your friend is smoking near that oxygen tank.Conclusion: You should tell your friend to move away from the tank.
C) Premises: The newspaper should cover all important stories.The election is an important story.Conclusion: The newspaper should cover the election.
D) Premises: My mother says I have a nice smile.My father says I have a nice smile.Conclusion: I have a nice smile.
E) Premises: Yoga is very relaxing.Relaxation would improve my heart health.Conclusion: Yoga would improve my heart health.
Independent Premises
Statements or claims in an argument that support the conclusion independently of each other.
Water Level
The height reached by the surface of a body of water, often measured in relation to a specific reference point.
Oxygen Tank
A container for storing oxygen under pressure, often used for medical purposes or in scuba diving.
- Recognize the role of independent and dependent premises in argument structure.
Verified Answer
RA
Reaper ActualMay 04, 2024
Final Answer :
D
Explanation :
The premises in argument D are independent because each parent's opinion about the speaker's smile is not influenced by the other parent's opinion.
Learning Objectives
- Recognize the role of independent and dependent premises in argument structure.