Asked by Sydney Tuttle on May 16, 2024

verifed

Verified

In which scenario will the court likely find the contract void on the grounds of mistake?

A) Annette bought a suit thinking she would be invited back for a second interview. She wasn't, and now wants to return the suit on the basis of mistake.
B) Ms. Hunt bought some property erroneously thinking that the province was planning to put a highway nearby, even though the seller had never made any such suggestion. She wants out of the contract.
C) The parties signed a document that stated the consideration as $1100 instead of the $900 that the buyer and seller had contracted for, but the buyer cannot prove the terms of the original contract.
D) Mr. Armstrong accepted an offer by Sidhu, who was selling a "computer program," but learned that they had different understandings of what program was meant. The court cannot say that one interpretation is better than the other.
E) Mary contracted to buy "the Acura car" from a collector of cars. He was selling his 2011 model but she thought she was buying the 2012 model. The court, looking at all the evidence, found that his interpretation was the more reasonable.

Consideration

The worth, including currency, services, or items, that is traded between entities in an agreement.

Contract Void

A contract void is a contract that is deemed legally nonexistent and unenforceable from the outset, due to illegality or other serious defects.

  • Understand the circumstances under which a contract might be considered void due to mistakes.
verifed

Verified Answer

VV
victoriarose vendittiMay 19, 2024
Final Answer :
D
Explanation :
In scenario D, the court is likely to find the contract void on the grounds of mistake because there was a mutual misunderstanding between Mr. Armstrong and Sidhu about what constituted the "computer program" being sold. This fundamental difference in understanding about the subject matter of the contract means that there was no meeting of the minds, which is essential for a valid contract.